roofing
Asphalt Shingles vs Metal Roofing
Metal costs 2x more but lasts 2-3x longer with lower energy bills. If staying 15+ years, metal often has lower total cost of ownership.
Option A
Asphalt Shingles
$4-$8
per sq ft
Lifespan20-30 years
MaintenanceMedium - inspect and repair as needed
Pros
- ✓Lower upfront cost
- ✓Easy to repair
- ✓Many styles/colors
- ✓Familiar to contractors
Cons
- ✗Shorter lifespan
- ✗Less energy efficient
- ✗Weather damage risk
- ✗Heavier
Best for: Budget-conscious homeowners or those selling soon
Option B
Metal Roofing
$8-$16
per sq ft
Lifespan50-70 years
MaintenanceLow - occasional inspection
Pros
- ✓Lasts 2-3x longer
- ✓Energy efficient
- ✓Fire resistant
- ✓Lightweight
Cons
- ✗Higher upfront cost
- ✗Can be noisy in rain
- ✗Denting possible
- ✗Specialized install
Best for: Forever homes and energy-conscious owners
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Criteria | Asphalt Shingles | Metal Roofing | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upfront Cost | $4-8/sq ft ✓ | $8-16/sq ft | Asphalt Shingles |
| Lifespan | 20-30 years | 50-70 years ✓ | Metal Roofing |
| Energy Savings | Standard | 15-25% cooling savings ✓ | Metal Roofing |
| Maintenance | Regular repairs | Minimal ✓ | Metal Roofing |
| Resale Value | Standard | Premium ✓ | Metal Roofing |
| Installation Speed | 2-3 days ✓ | 3-5 days | Asphalt Shingles |
The Verdict
Metal costs 2x more but lasts 2-3x longer with lower energy bills. If staying 15+ years, metal often has lower total cost of ownership.
Choose Asphalt Shingles if:
Budget-conscious homeowners or those selling soon
Choose Metal Roofing if:
Forever homes and energy-conscious owners
Frequently Asked Questions
Is metal roofing worth the extra cost?
Yes, if you're staying 15+ years. Metal lasts 50-70 years vs 20-30 for asphalt, saving one full roof replacement ($15,000-$25,000). Plus you save $100-$300/year on cooling.
Are metal roofs noisy in the rain?
Modern metal roofs with proper insulation and solid sheathing are no louder than asphalt. The noise myth comes from old barn-style installations. Proper install eliminates this concern.
Do metal roofs attract lightning?
No, metal roofs don't attract lightning. If struck, metal dissipates the charge safely and won't catch fire like other materials. Metal is actually safer in lightning-prone areas.
Which roof has better resale value?
Metal roofs command a premium with buyers due to longevity and energy efficiency. Expect 1-6% higher sale price. New asphalt is neutral - expected but not exciting.
Can I put metal over asphalt shingles?
Often yes, if the existing roof is in decent shape with only one layer. This saves tear-off costs ($1,000-$3,000). Check local codes and have a contractor assess structural suitability.
More Comparisons
flooring
Hardwood vs Laminate Flooring
$6-$18 vs $3-$10
flooringHardwood vs Luxury Vinyl Plank (LVP)
$6-$18 vs $4-$10
flooringTile vs Luxury Vinyl Plank
$5-$15 vs $4-$10
roofingRoof Repair vs Replacement
$300-$1,500 vs $8,000-$20,000
kitchenGranite vs Quartz Countertops
$40-$100 vs $50-$150
kitchenReface vs Replace Kitchen Cabinets
$4,000-$10,000 vs $8,000-$25,000